Halibut in Heavy Cream

Fish entree
Image
For the Shakers, salt water fish was not considered a luxury as it often is today.
Number of servings: Serves 4-6

Ingredients

  • 3 pounds halibut in one piece
  • 2 teaspoons flour
  • salt and pepper
  • 6 teaspoons butter
  • 1/2 cup water
  • 1/2 cup cider
  • 1 1/2 cups heavy cream

Instructions

  1. Rub halibut with flour seasoned with salt and pepper.
  2. Butter a 2-quart baking dish, put fish in center, and use remaining butter to cover top of fish.
  3. Pour water and cider around it.
  4. Cover baking dish and cook for 20 minutes in moderate oven (325° F), basting when necessary as fish must not become dry.
  5. Add 1 cup heavy cream and cook another 15 or 20 minutes, increasing heat to 350°F.
  6. Baste when necessary.
  7.  Serve fish surrounded by very small new boiled potatoes.
  8. Strain sauce in which fish has cooked, add enough of the remaining cream to make a thick sauce. If not thick enough, add beaten yolks of 2 eggs.
  9. Pour over fish on platter.

Tips

Chervil, tarragon, and mushrooms combined with lemon juice make excellent flavorings for sauces with fish.

The heads, backbones, and tails of fish should be cooked with a dab of marjoram and thyme for half an hour; the liquid may be used in making sauces or for chowders.

Green onions and parsley stewed in butter and combined with two cups of fish broth, poured over 2 slightly beaten eggs make a delectable sauce for boiled or baked fish.

Recipes from Mary Whitcher of Harvard Shaker Village, renowned as a good cook and housekeeper.

More Shaker Recipes...

Pea Roast

Although the “meatless diet” only lasted ten years (1837 – 1847), it was observed in most communities, but not strictly…
Featured image for “Pea Roast”
Featured image for “Pea Roast”
Although the “meatless diet” only lasted ten years (1837 – 1847), it was observed in most communities, but not strictly…

Cabbage Pie

All vegetables were grown locally; there was a constant succession of different crops.…
Featured image for “Cabbage Pie”
Featured image for “Cabbage Pie”
All vegetables were grown locally; there was a constant succession of different crops.…

Applesauce

This recipe uses dried apples and concentrated cider.…
Featured image for “Applesauce”
Featured image for “Applesauce”
This recipe uses dried apples and concentrated cider.…

Herbade (Hancock Shakers)

This is how the Shakers at Hancock Shaker Village made their herbade…
Featured image for “Herbade (Hancock Shakers)”
Featured image for “Herbade (Hancock Shakers)”
This is how the Shakers at Hancock Shaker Village made their herbade…

Herbade (Harvard Shakers)

This is a refreshing beverage from the Harvard Shaker Village.…
Featured image for “Herbade (Harvard Shakers)”
Featured image for “Herbade (Harvard Shakers)”
This is a refreshing beverage from the Harvard Shaker Village.…

Fried Fresh Peaches

A recipe from “The Best of Shaker Cooking,” revised and expanded by Amy Bess and Persis Fuller.…
Featured image for “Fried Fresh Peaches”
Featured image for “Fried Fresh Peaches”
A recipe from “The Best of Shaker Cooking,” revised and expanded by Amy Bess and Persis Fuller.…

Cucumber Salad

“It does not seem generally known that the cucumber is one of the most valuable vegetables we raise. It can…
Featured image for “Cucumber Salad”
Featured image for “Cucumber Salad”
“It does not seem generally known that the cucumber is one of the most valuable vegetables we raise. It can…

Corn Relish

Corn relish is a type of condiment made from corn kernels that are typically mixed with various other ingredients. It’s…
Featured image for “Corn Relish”
Featured image for “Corn Relish”
Corn relish is a type of condiment made from corn kernels that are typically mixed with various other ingredients. It’s…

See all...